https://fremont.hostmaster.org/postings/1774607771579368274
Home | Articles | Postings | Weather | Top | Trending | Status
Login
If any other country arrested children, prosecuted them in military courts with a conviction rate of more than 98% and jailed them in military prisons where they're exposed to torture and starvation... ...the US would feel compelled to liberate that country by dropping a whole lot of bombs on it.
### Breakdown and Verification of the Core Claims The reply makes three interlocking factual assertions about Israel's treatment of Palestinian children in the West Bank (under military law). These align closely with long-standing documentation from Israeli, Palestinian, and international human rights organizations. Here's the evidence: 1. **Arrest and military prosecution of children**: Israel is the only country that systematically tries children (ages 12-17) in military courts. Between 500 and 700 Palestinian children from the occupied West Bank are arrested, prosecuted, and imprisoned this way each year. Since 2000, roughly 13,000 have gone through the system. Israeli children living in the same territory (settlers) are tried in civilian courts under Israeli law, creating two parallel legal systems. Palestinian children are often arrested at night by armed soldiers, transferred out of the West Bank (in violation of the Fourth Geneva Convention's prohibition on transferring protected persons), and frequently held without access to a lawyer during initial interrogation. Many cases involve stone-throwing allegations (Walid Ahmad's reported charge). 2. **Conviction rate >98%**: This is accurate and consistently reported across sources. U.S. State Department reports, B'Tselem, Defense for Children International – Palestine (DCIP), and Military Court Watch have documented rates of 95–99.7% (often cited as >99%). The vast majority of cases end in plea bargains because children and families see conviction as inevitable; trials are rare. 3. **Exposure to torture and starvation in military prisons**: Multiple independent sources document widespread, systematic ill-treatment. DCIP, B'Tselem, Save the Children, UNICEF (2013 report and updates), and recent UN experts describe beatings, sexual violence/abuse, solitary confinement, painful restraints, denial of medical care, family visits, and basic needs. Post-October 2023, conditions worsened dramatically: administrative detention (no charge/trial) now affects a record 51% of Palestinian child detainees (as of end-2025), up sharply. UN Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese's March 2026 report called Israeli prisons a "laboratory of calculated cruelty" and "torture... state doctrine," citing deliberate caloric reduction policies, forced nudity, genital violence, and dehumanization. Walid Ahmad's case is cited explicitly as an example of starvation-related death amid systemic neglect. The UN has verified specific incidents of conflict-related sexual violence against Palestinian male detainees (including minors) in facilities like Megiddo. These patterns predate 2023 but intensified afterward, per NGOs and UN bodies. Israel has made some procedural changes over the years (e.g., juvenile military courts, limits on certain practices), but critics say they are insufficient and do not address the core discriminatory structure.
Impressions: 6